arXiv 预发布与 ICLR 双盲评审如何共存?
How does arXiv prepublishing work with ICLR's double-blind review? [R]
一位博士生在 r/MachineLearning 提问:ICLR 投稿中不少论文此前已在 arXiv 预发布,这是否破坏双盲评审。该用户称只要用 Google 搜索论文标题或摘要片段就能找到预印本,并因担心 desk-reject 而避免预发布。
Hey folks,
maybe a really dumb question from an inexperienced PhD student. I recently submitted to ICLR and spotted a bunch of papers that I was already familiar with because I had seen them on arXiv before.
Doesn't this break the double-blind review process? I mean, on the one hand, people pre-publishing their work want to establish priority as quickly as possible, but on the other hand, they still want their papers to be treated as valid submissions in a double-blind review system.
I generally avoid pre-publishing my work for this reason, although this can cause some trouble when it comes to novelty claims, because I'm worried about getting desk-rejected.
I mean, I can just Google the paper title or even parts of the abstract and immediately find the preprint. It seems quite frustrating...
submitted by /u/richapeee
[link] [留言]
来源:r/MachineLearning · reddit.com