审稿人会把评审意见上传给 AI 吗？[D]

To reviewers: do you upload your review to an AI? (NOT the paper itself) [D]

AI 导读

一位审稿人表示，自己如今在完成评审后会额外把评审意见上传给 AI 征求二次意见，但从不上传被评审的论文本身，认为论文是否交给 AI 应由作者自己决定。这样做虽然增加了工作量，但多数情况下产出了更高质量的评审，错别字也更少。

正文

The way I review a paper has stayed substantially the same, except for an added step. Trying to get a sense of how common it is here.

Nowadays I do the review, and I upload my review to an AI to ask for second thoughts. I don't ever upload a paper I'm reviewing, though. The authors can do it themselves (if they want to, it's their call).

So in the end, it's even more work for me. Not fun. But it has produced higher quality reviews, most of the time. And less typos.

submitted by /u/StingMeleoron
[link] [留言]