ICLR 投稿因半句话溢出第 10 页被 desk rejection，作者质疑官方 LLM 反馈未检出格式问题

Crashing out after ICLR desk rejection: "content exceeds the 9-page limit." [D]

AI 导读

一名作者因论文中半句话延伸到第 10 页、超出 9 页限制，被 ICLR desk rejection。作者称这可能是重新提交时小幅编辑并重新编译 PDF 所致，并质疑官方提供的 LLM 反馈未能检出这一格式错误，认为其无法帮助作者发现会导致 desk rejection 的低级排版问题。

正文

Half of one sentence in my paper trails onto page 10...

This must have happened after a small edit and recompile of the pdf on resubmission?

but this got me desk rejected??? Is this normal?? This wasn't even flagged by the official LLM feedback?

Like whats the point of providing LLM feedback if it can't catch this. I don't need an AI slop breakdown of my papers strengths and weaknesses, I need to know that i didn't miss any ridiculous formatting mistakes that would lead to a desk rejection.

This whole thing feels criminal and humiliating :(

Especially after already being de-anonymized...

submitted by /u/Eclectic_eels
[link] [留言]